A Violent Separation | Film Review

-

 

I heard about this film ages ago, and added it to my to-watch list. But I don't remember hearing about it since, and so I forgot about it. However, it recently came on the Sky Premiere channel, so I finally got the chance to watch it.

Police deputy Norman Young (Brenton Thwaites) covers up a murder committed by his brother, only for things to become complicated when Norman falls in love with the victim's sister.

After I watched the movie, the first review I saw said something along the lines of 'Everyone watched this movie for the cast, not the plot'. I watched it for Claire Holt, who plays Abbey, so that review is definitely true for me!

This isn't a great film at all. For a start, it assumes that we care about these characters, but it gives us nothing to care about. The characters, the story, there's not really anything there.

None of these characters feel like real people. It's not that the premise of the story is particularly far-fetched, but that everything the characters do and say feels unrealistic.

In addition to that, the events of the story feel really passive for the audience. We are not living this story with the characters, we are observing, but the story isn't interesting enough to make that observation worth it.

The film tries to do too much, and take on too many themes. What this leaves is an attempt to work through a theme that never gets finished.

The thing about this film is that the premise could have allowed for a lot of avenues. It could have been a thriller, or a twisted romance, but what we ended up with was a lacklustre drama. It could have taken a lot of interesting routes, but every single one of them was ignored.

The cardinal sin of this film is that it's boring. Even with it being what it is, a few small changes could have made it interesting. I wanted to care about what happened to the characters, but I just didn't. Even the dramatic climax didn't help it.

Overall, I wouldn't really recommend the film, and I doubt I'll ever watch it again. There are much better films out there with similar premises.   

1.5/10



Comments

Post a Comment

Thank you so much for your comment xx

Popular Posts

The Good, the Bad and the Ugly | 100 Movies Bucket List

-
Image
Next on the list was 'The Good, the Bad and the Ugly'. This isn't one I was particularly looking forward to.  I've never been a huge fan of Westerns, so watching what is probably the most famous Western for 2 and a half hours wasn't high on my to-do list.  But because of that, it was actually a much more intriguing watch than I thought it would be. It took me quite a while to really get into it, but once I got the plot and focused on it, I found the story was a great one. What made it great for me more than anything was the characters. I really enjoyed watching them interact. And as someone who had only seen Clint Eastwood in 'The Bridges of Madison County' and 'Million Dollar Baby' before this, I definitely gained a newfound respect for him as an actor. Whenever I think of Westerns, my mind instantly goes to 'Back to the Future 3', even though the actual movies aren't like this in any way. But this movie was the first to directly remind
Read more

The Usual Suspects | 100 Movies Bucket List

-
Image
  This is the second movie for the bucket list that I forgot to write a post for! I saw this back in May so my memory might be a bit rusty, but it was a re-watch so I'm pretty clear on the plot and how I feel about it. I liked this movie. I probably liked it the same amount this time that I did on my first watch. It's a great story, told in a really interesting way. And while I probably didn't find it completely interesting the whole way through, it was worth it to get to the twist. For me, a plot twist is such an underrated device. I love them so much I actively seek them out in both movies and books. A good plot twist can make an otherwise bad movie re-watch-worthy. There are a few twisty movies on the bucket list, and this one has one of the best twists. Even if you don't like the movie as a whole, the twist makes everything so much more interesting. Another thing the twist does is make you want to watch the film all over again. I saw it months ago now, and I really
Read more

Woman of the Hour | Film Review

-
Image
  Amidst a series of murders in LA, aspiring actress Cheryl (Anna Kendrick) crosses paths with a serial killer (Daniel Zovatto) on a dating show. I was really excited to see this film as soon as I saw the trailer. Even in that short space of time it got across a tense, sinister atmosphere that made the film seem like a really interesting watch, especially being a true story. Thankfully I loved the film, and the atmosphere it created was part of the reason why. From the first scene we understand the tone and can already kind of guess how the rest of the film will feel. The tension was created expertly. There were multiple times while watching the film where I was holding my breath without realising, and this feeling didn't go away until the film was over. In the last 30 minutes particularly, I actually had to pause the film to remind myself to breathe because it was that intense. Those 30 minutes were so well written and crafted - I don't think I've even seen a full-on horro
Read more

Subservience | Film Review

-
Image
While struggling with a sick wife and two children, Nick (Michele Morrone) hires an AI android called Alice (Megan Fox) to help out around the house. But when Alice becomes self-aware, Nick finds that he and his family are suddenly in danger. I've watched a few AI-based horror movies in the last month or so, so I was in the mood to give another one a shot. As I'd somewhat enjoyed the others, I thought I'd like this one too. Unfortunately, I didn't like this one much at all. For a start (and this is my fault as I've already mentioned seeing a few films with this concept recently) but the AI-gone-bad premise is no longer new. And when a film uses the concept but doesn't bring any new ideas, it starts feeling a bit stale. This one didn't really have anything new to add to that conversation, and so it didn't feel original. Having said that, I did like that it got right into the story straight away. We know the family, we know their circumstances, we know how
Read more

Smile 2 | Film Review

-
Image
After a harrowing accident, popstar Skye Riley (Naomi Scott) is putting her life back together and embarking on a world tour. But after witnessing a suicide, she begins to experience strange occurrences - the strangest of which is a smile that seems to follow her wherever she goes...  Having absolutely loved the first film, I was so excited to see where this next one would take the storyline, and it seemed really promising! But my high expectations were probably why I ended up being so disappointed with the final result. I know that this is definitely an unpopular opinion, but I didn't really like this sequel. However, I did like how it began. It directly connects itself to the first film in a really interesting way, and that was fun to watch. Then it kind of went downhill. For me personally, I didn't love the character of Skye Riley. I didn't really feel connected to her, and it never felt like the film allowed me to get to know her that well. So as much as the events are
Read more