Book Review: One of Us is Guilty by Steve Cavanagh

 

When a woman is murdered, her lover and his wife are the main suspects. But is one of them guilty? And if so, which one?

I'm a huge fan of Steve Cavanagh, particularly when it comes to his Eddie Flynn series, which this book is part of. So I was looking forward to seeing where this one would go.

I liked this book - it had a great premise and it played out well.

It was great being back with the familiar characters that we've grown to love.

But the most important thing about each of these stories is the case we're solving, and this is one of the more interesting ones.

We get a nice amount of backstory in the characters, which allows us to form our own opinions of what actually happened and how everything will play out. It's fun to make guesses and try to put the pieces together alongside the characters.

The characters feel authentic, although maybe described in a different way from how you imagine. Of course this is just personal but I definitely imagined the main characters as older than they were, and I feel like that may have worked better for the story.

The build-up to the reveal is slower than in previous stories. There seem to be less pieces to put together, which isn't necessarily a bad thing, as there's less space for red herrings and pointless plot lines.

That being said, this did allow the story to be more predictable than it may have been otherwise.

It's hard to connect with any of the characters outside of the ones we already know because we're wary of them all.

The reveal wasn't as surprising or exciting as it could be. Things were tied up too neatly and there were too many coincidences. There were also some aspects of the reveal that came out earlier than they needed to.

But overall, this is a well-told, well-written story with a really interesting premise. It's one of the better Eddie Flynn novels and I'd definitely recommend it.

3.5/5




Comments

Popular Posts

Animals | Film Review

Insidious: Out of the Further | Film Review

The Others | 100 Movies Bucket List

Ramble About Youtube | Response To Jack Howard

Spider-Man: Brand New Day | Film Review